Progestogen intolerance
A 50-year-old on sequential estradiol plus norethisterone reports 10 days of low mood, bloating and irritability each cycle. VMS are well controlled. She wants to stop everything.
Best next step?
From 'she needs HRT' to an actual prescription — with endometrial protection you can defend.
A defensible default for a symptomatic 52-year-old with a uterus: transdermal estradiol 50 micrograms/24h patch twice weekly (or 1–2 pumps of gel daily), plus micronised progesterone 100 mg nightly continuously if she is more than 12 months postmenopausal, or 200 mg nightly for 12 days per month if she is still bleeding. Review at 3 months for dose titration, then annually. Add vaginal oestrogen separately if genitourinary symptoms persist.
Non-response usually means under-dosing, poor absorption or the wrong diagnosis. Patch absorption falls with high BMI and with application to the wrong site; gel absorption varies with skin surface. Estradiol levels can guide titration in poor responders and in POI, where target physiological levels are higher. For progestogen intolerance, consider LNG-IUS, lower-dose continuous micronised progesterone, or vaginal progesterone off-label with informed consent.
Oral oestrogen raises SHBG, CRP and triglycerides and lowers free testosterone — clinically relevant in women with low libido or hypertriglyceridaemia. Progestogen receptor pharmacology differs meaningfully: MPA has glucocorticoid and partial androgenic activity, norethisterone is androgenic and partly metabolised to ethinylestradiol, while micronised progesterone is neutral to mildly anti-mineralocorticoid with GABA-A active allopregnanolone metabolites — the mechanism behind its sedative effect.
“Compounded 'bioidentical' hormone pellets are safer because they're customised to your levels.”
Compounded preparations are not subject to the same batch consistency, purity or labelling requirements, salivary monitoring has no analytic validity, and pellets deliver supraphysiological, non-reversible doses with documented endometrial hyperplasia cases. Regulator-approved body-identical estradiol and micronised progesterone deliver the same molecules with quality assurance.
Transdermal estradiol does not increase VTE risk
Supported in defined populations — Consistent observational and nested case-control data (ESTHER, UK CPRD).
Systemic oestrogen without a progestogen in a woman with a uterus causes endometrial hyperplasia and carcinoma
Established — RCT / guideline-grade — Established; unopposed oestrogen is never acceptable with an intact uterus.
The LNG-IUS provides adequate endometrial protection with systemic oestrogen
Established — RCT / guideline-grade — Licensed for this indication in many jurisdictions; typically 4–5 years of protection.
Micronised progesterone carries lower breast cancer risk than synthetic progestins
Promising but preliminary — Observational (E3N) signal; no RCT with breast cancer endpoints.
Compounded bioidentical hormones are safer than regulated preparations
Refuted or actively misleading — No supporting evidence; documented harms and regulatory warnings.
Testosterone supplementation improves hypoactive sexual desire disorder in postmenopausal women
Supported in defined populations — Global Consensus Position Statement 2019 — supported for HSDD only, at female physiological doses.
A 50-year-old on sequential estradiol plus norethisterone reports 10 days of low mood, bloating and irritability each cycle. VMS are well controlled. She wants to stop everything.
Best next step?
A 54-year-old with BMI 34 and a previous provoked DVT needs MHT for severe VMS. Best route?
A woman with an intact uterus, 3 years postmenopause, starting estradiol gel. Which is appropriate?
Persistent unscheduled bleeding at 9 months on continuous combined MHT. Next step?
A 51-year-old on sequential MHT asks about contraception. Correct advice?